Fans of Korean popular music, or K-pop, are using their fandom to drown out racist criticism of the George Floyd protests on social media by flooding certain Twitter hashtags with videos of pop stars.
Hashtags such as “White Lives Matter” and “Blue Lives Matter,” which have often been used to criticize the Black Lives Matter movement, were overwhelmed on Wednesday with seemingly unrelated K-pop videos and gifs.
why is it 8am and i am literally teary eyed that kpop twitter hijacked the #WhiteLivesMatter hashtag to drown out the racism and fill with fancams and petitions like…..never DRAG THEM AGAIN. kpop stans are FOR THE PEOPLE.
— elijah daniel (@elijahdaniel) June 3, 2020
— ✨fico✨ (@puertofico) June 3, 2020
Kpop stans ready to take over another hashtag #WhiteLivesMatter
— Presh ⁷ bangteez/busy with school (@eternal_jungkoo) June 3, 2020
Many of the posts were so-called “fan cams,” a popular K-pop trend in which users share live performance clips of their favourite artists.
The K-pop posts referred to the hashtags as racist — a criticism sometimes levelled against statements that try to deflect the “Black Lives Matter” slogan to highlight some other group, such as white people, police or all people.
Alicia Garza, one of the founders of the Black Lives Matter movement, explained in 2016 that her group’s slogan is not meant to diminish others. It’s simply meant to highlight that the systems of society don’t treat Black lives as though they’re worth the same as other lives.
“We do believe that all lives matter,” she said during a speech at Portland State University in 2016, as reported by local station KATU. “But we don’t live in a world where all lives matter, so that kind of response really puts on display the very issues we’re trying to address.”
“White Lives Matter” is a “white supremacist phrase” and a “racist response” to the Black Lives Matter movement, according to the Anti-Defamation League. The phrase has also inspired a white supremacist group to adopt the name, according to the Southern Poverty Law Center. Racist groups have been using the phrase as a slogan for at least five years.
Many social media users applauded the K-pop community’s tongue-in-cheek effort to tackle racism on Wednesday, with thousands of users liking tweets about the takeover.
i saw #whitelivesmatter trending number 1 & #bluelivesmatter at number 2 and was gonna loSE IT
but it’s all kpop stans posting fancams and pics of blue power rangers lmaoooo pic.twitter.com/C8WzKrOa7A
— geo (@lovesickgeorgia) June 3, 2020
— Dhruvi⁷⧖ – crying bc of apush📚 (@bxubbleggukk) June 3, 2020
— ♡︎ gigi ♡︎ (@gigi_hadidn_t) June 3, 2020
Among those applauding the move was @YourAnonCentral, an account that has long claimed to represent the Anonymous movement on Twitter. The account is unverified but it has been active for years and currently has more than 5.8 million followers.
The account praised the “Anonymous K-Pop division” on Wednesday for a “major victory over online fascism’s messaging tools.” More than 57,000 people liked the tweet.
Report from the battle: The Anonymous K-Pop division #OpFanCam has successfully conquered the #BlueLivesMatter and #WhiteLivesMatter hashtags. A major victory over online fascism's messaging tools, their fascist incel troops have been completely decimated.
— Anonymous (@YourAnonCentral) June 3, 2020
The “MAGA” hashtag, a popular abbreviation for U.S. President Donald Trump’s “Make America Great Again” slogan, was also partially flooded with K-pop clips on Wednesday afternoon, although those tweets failed to overwhelm that community.
Many allies of the Black community also pounced on a trend called “Whiteout Wednesday,” an apparent response to “Blackout Tuesday” during which the music industry halted its operations and many people shared black squares on social media to support the protests.
— ✨fico✨ (@puertofico) June 3, 2020
— Josiah Johnson (@KingJosiah54) June 3, 2020
Some took the hashtag more literally by sharing images of correction fluid.
— Waiting and Watching (@WTFisallathis) June 3, 2020
The tweets appear to have largely drowned far-right white nationalists such as Katie Hopkins and Faith Goldy, who had also been trying to make “Whiteout Wednesday” a thing.
It’s unclear how the K-pop backlash started, although this is the second time in a week that K-pop fan cams have intervened to help the protests. On Sunday, fans reportedly flooded a Dallas Police Department app with videos after police asked for clips of “illegal activity” from the protests. Dozens of users also posted clips in response to a department tweet.
Police shut down the app “due to technical difficulties” later that day.
© 2020 Global News, a division of Corus Entertainment Inc.